Software licences

Microsoft 365 licences: plans, inactive accounts, right-sizing

Updated 5 min readMarkdown
In short

Microsoft 365 licences are reduced in four places. Licences that were bought and are assigned to nobody. Accounts that are blocked or belong to people who left and still hold a licence. Accounts nobody has signed in to for months. And people on a higher plan than their work needs. The first three can be read from the tenant, the fourth cannot, because a sign-in does not show which applications a person uses, so it is a question to the holder. Price every candidate with what your invoice says per licence, and bring the list to the renewal, when the number of licences can be lowered.

The Microsoft 365 licences you can drop or downgrade are found in four places: licences nobody holds, accounts that are blocked or orphaned, accounts nobody signs in to, and people on a plan above what they need. Three of the four can be read from the tenant. The fourth needs a question, because Microsoft's directory records that someone signed in and not what they did afterwards.

What you pay for

Microsoft 365 is sold as subscriptions to plans, each with a number of licences. A licence is assigned to a user account. You pay for the number purchased, whether or not every licence is assigned. Two families matter for most companies:

FamilyPlans (examples)Remark
BusinessBusiness Basic, Business Standard, Business Premium, Apps for businessLimited to 300 users per plan
Enterprise and frontlineOffice 365 E1, E3, E5; Microsoft 365 E3, E5; Microsoft 365 F3No user limit

What each plan contains changes. Take it from Microsoft's plan comparison on the day you decide and not from memory or from an article. This page states no prices for the same reason: the price that counts is the one on your invoice.

Step 1: compare purchased with assigned

For each plan, put the number of licences purchased next to the number assigned. The difference is paid for and used by nobody. Keep a small buffer for new starters, decide how large it is, and write the rest down as removable. This is the least contentious finding, because nobody loses anything.

Step 2: blocked accounts and leavers

A blocked account keeps its licence. So does the account of someone who left, as long as nobody unassigns it. Compare the licensed accounts with the list of current employees. For each account that matches nobody, decide what happens to the mailbox and the files first; Microsoft documents ways to keep a leaver's mailbox without a user licence. The order of work is described in licences at offboarding.

Step 3: accounts without a sign-in

Microsoft Graph returns the last sign-in per account in the signInActivity property. It is only available in tenants with Microsoft Entra ID P1 or P2, which some plans include and others do not. Choose an inactivity period and list the licensed accounts whose last sign-in is older, and separately those that never signed in.

Read the date for what it is. It is a sign-in to the directory, interactive or in the background. A phone that still syncs mail keeps an account looking active. And an account without a recent sign-in can be a shared mailbox account, a room, or someone on parental leave. The list is a list of people to ask, as described in how to find unused software licences.

Step 4: the fitting plan per person

For each pair of plans in use, write one sentence on what the higher one adds. Between Business Basic and Business Standard it is mainly the desktop applications. Business Premium adds device management and security functions. In the Enterprise family, E5 adds advanced security and compliance to E3.

Then find out, per holder, whether that addition is used. The last sign-in cannot tell you. The usage reports of the Microsoft 365 admin center show activity for some applications and can be exported. For everything else, ask: "Do you work with the installed Office applications, or in the browser?" is a question people can answer. The method, with thresholds and a decision table, is in right-sizing SaaS plans.

Functions the organisation uses as a whole, such as conditional access or audit logs, do not show in any person's usage. A move of everyone to a lower plan needs a written list of required functions from the administrator first.

Step 5: compute and time it

A worked example with invented, round figures. 100 licences of a plan are purchased at 10.00 a month each. 88 are assigned; you keep a buffer of 4. Of the assigned accounts, 6 are blocked or belong to leavers.

FindingCalculationPer year
Never assigned(100 − 88 − 4) × 10.00 × 12960.00
Blocked accounts and leavers6 × 10.00 × 12720.00
Total1,680.00

Nine more accounts had no sign-in for 90 days. They are a list of questions and are not in the total until the holders have answered.

On a term with a commitment, the number of licences can usually be lowered at the renewal and not before. So the list needs a date: see preparing a SaaS renewal. The billing cycle is a separate question for the reseller or for Microsoft.

What goes wrong

  • Unassigning without lowering the count. A freed licence still costs money until the subscription is reduced.
  • Treating the sign-in date as usage. It says the account was reached, nothing more.
  • Forgetting the tenant's own plan. Without Entra ID P1 or P2 there is no sign-in data, and missing data is not inactivity.
  • Downgrading away a function everyone relies on. Security and compliance functions hang on the plan, not on a person.
  • Calculating with list prices. They ignore your agreement and may be out of date.

How Cureman does it

Cureman has a connector for Microsoft 365 that only reads. It uses three read-only Microsoft Graph application permissions and reads the purchased licence plans with their number of licences, every user account with its assigned licences and last sign-in, and the employee directory with department and manager. Blocked accounts that still hold a licence stay in the count as billable. It does not read per-application usage of Teams, Outlook or Office, and without Entra ID P1 or P2 in the tenant no accounts are imported, which the connection reports as an error. The connector is marked beta: it stays so until it has been run against a live tenant.

From this data Cureman computes licences that are purchased and unassigned beyond a buffer, licences of people who left, and accounts inactive for the period the organisation sets, each with its calculation. Whether a holder needs their plan is asked, in a message a person approves before it is sent. A lower plan for everyone is only quantified once the required functions are recorded. Prices in the catalogue are seed or researched list prices, labelled unverified until a person has verified them; a finding that rests on one says so. Nothing is changed in the tenant. The module is described on the page about licence optimisation.

Questions and answers

Which Microsoft 365 licences can usually be dropped?

Licences that are bought and assigned to nobody, licences on blocked accounts and on accounts of people who left, and licences of accounts with no sign-in for a period you set. The first group needs no question to anyone. For the others, ask the holder or the manager before removing anything, because a missing sign-in is a reason to ask and not proof.

Does a blocked account still cost a licence?

Yes. Blocking the sign-in does not remove the licence. The licence stays assigned and is billed until someone unassigns it, and the number of purchased licences only falls when it is lowered in the subscription. Check what happens to the mailbox and files before unassigning.

How do I find inactive Microsoft 365 accounts?

From the last sign-in of each account, which Microsoft Graph returns for tenants with Microsoft Entra ID P1 or P2. Compare the date with an inactivity period you choose. Keep in mind that the date is a sign-in to the directory, including background token refreshes, and says nothing about which application was used.

How do I know whether a person needs a higher plan?

Write down what the higher plan adds, for example desktop applications, device management or advanced security and compliance functions, and find out whether the person uses it. Sign-in data cannot answer that. Usage reports in the Microsoft 365 admin center help for some applications, and for the rest the reliable source is a short question to the holder.

Are the Microsoft 365 prices in a price catalogue reliable?

Only after someone has compared them with Microsoft's own price page or with your invoice. List prices change, differ by country and billing cycle, and say nothing about what you negotiated. Use the price per licence from your invoice where you have it, and mark every figure that rests on an unverified list price.