Software licences

Preparing a SaaS renewal

Updated 6 min readMarkdown
In short

A SaaS renewal is prepared against the notice date, not the renewal date. The notice date is the renewal date minus the notice period, and after it the contract usually continues unchanged for another term. Before it, establish how many seats are needed (paid, assigned, active, released), which tier each holder needs, and what the users say. Then write to the vendor with specific requests, each backed by your own figures, and count a concession only when it is quoted in writing.

A SaaS renewal is prepared backwards from one date: the last day on which the contract can still be changed. The work before that date is to know how many seats and which tiers the organisation needs, and to ask the vendor for exactly that. After that date there is usually nothing left to prepare.

The two dates

Every contract with a term has a renewal date and a notice period. The notice date is the renewal date minus the notice period. If the term ends on 30 June and the contract requires 60 days' notice, notice must reach the vendor by 1 May.

Read three things in the contract or order form, not on the invoice:

  • Automatic renewal. Does the contract continue unless cancelled, and for how long?
  • What notice covers. Under many contracts a reduction of seats is treated like a partial cancellation and has to be declared by the notice date as well.
  • Form. Is an email to the account manager enough, or does notice have to go to a named address?

Monthly plans have no such date. A reduction applies from the next invoice.

A timeline

WhenWhat
Twelve weeks before the notice dateRead seats, tiers and activity; ask seat holders; survey users
Eight weeks beforeSeat count and plan mix are settled with the application's owner
Six weeks beforeWrite to the vendor with the requests
Two weeks beforeVendor's answer in writing; decide
By the notice dateDeclare the reduction, the change or the cancellation in the form the contract requires
After renewalRecord the new term, price and notice date

Step 1: the seat count

Start from what is paid and subtract what the data and the holders tell you.

LineSource
Seats paidSubscription
minus seats assigned to nobodyPaid minus assigned
minus seats of people who have leftSeat list joined with the directory
minus seats released by their holdersAnswers to the usage question
plus seats for planned joinersThe application's owner
= seats to renew

Inactive seats whose holders have not answered stay in the count. They are in question, not released. The method is described in how to find unused software licences.

A worked example with invented figures: 100 seats paid at 20.00 a month. 4 are unassigned, 3 belong to people who left, 11 were released by their holders, and the owner expects no growth. 100 − 4 − 3 − 11 = 82 seats to renew. The reduction is 18 × 20.00 × 12 = 4,320.00 a year.

Step 2: the plan mix

For the seats that stay, check whether every holder needs the tier they hold, and whether the organisation needs the plan it is on. This is covered in right-sizing SaaS plans. The result is a second list for the vendor: so many seats on the higher tier, so many on the lower.

If a second application does the same job, the renewal is also the moment to decide which of the two to keep. See overlapping SaaS tools.

Step 3: hear the users

Before a large renewal, ask the people who use the application two things: do you still need it, and what works badly or is missing? The answers change no individual seat. They tell you whether to renew at all, and they give you points to raise with the vendor that are not about price.

Step 4: what to ask the vendor for

Write one message with numbered requests. Each has a basis the vendor can check.

RequestBasis
Renew a lower number of seatsThe seat count from step 1
Move a number of seats to the lower tierThe plan mix from step 2
Match the published list priceYour price per seat is above the vendor's own price page for the same plan and billing cycle
Apply a published offer (annual prepayment, a multi-year term, a programme for your kind of organisation)You meet the conditions the vendor publishes
Cap the price increase for the following termsThe increase announced for this renewal
A shorter notice period, or the right to reduce seats during the termYour seat count has moved during the past term
Align the end dates of several contracts with the same vendorOne renewal to prepare instead of several

Two rules for the message. State only what is true: do not mention a competing offer you do not have. And keep requests about seats apart from requests about price. A vendor that grants a lower price for the old seat count has sold you the unused seats again.

A concession counts when the vendor has quoted it in writing. Until then it is a request, and a published offer is a ceiling on what might be granted, not a saving.

Step 5: decide and declare

By the notice date there are three outcomes: renew as agreed with the vendor, renew reduced on the existing terms, or cancel. If the vendor has not answered in time, declare the reduction anyway, in the form the contract requires, and keep negotiating. A reduction declared in time can be turned into a better agreement later. A missed date cannot be undone.

What goes wrong

  • The calendar holds the renewal date. By then the notice date has passed by weeks.
  • Negotiating price before fixing seats. The discount is applied to seats nobody needs.
  • Counting seats in question. The owner agrees to 70 seats, 80 people turn out to need one, and the missing seats are bought at a higher price during the term.
  • Accepting a longer term for a lower price without checking the total. Compare the whole term, and check whether seats can be reduced during it.
  • An agreement by phone. What is not in the order form does not exist at the next renewal.

How Cureman does it

Cureman reads the renewal date and the notice period with the subscription and raises a finding when a committed term renews within 90 days. The finding names the notice date, shows seats purchased next to seats in active use and says how many inactive seats can be dropped at renewal. It carries no saving of its own, and it gets a row in the list of decisions whatever it is worth once the deadline is close. Offers a vendor publishes are listed when the organisation meets their conditions, with a ceiling, and are never counted as savings, because nobody has quoted them. Users can be asked with a renewal survey that changes no seat. A message to the vendor is drafted as a step of the action plan and goes out only after a person approved it; the reply is filed in the same conversation, and a follow-up is prepared if the vendor stays silent. See the page about licence optimisation.

Questions and answers

When should preparation for a SaaS renewal start?

Early enough to finish before the notice date, which is the renewal date minus the notice period in the contract. Twelve weeks before the notice date is a workable start for a large subscription, because asking seat holders and getting an answer from the vendor each take weeks. For a contract with 60 days' notice that means starting about five months before the renewal date.

What is the difference between the renewal date and the notice date?

The renewal date is when the new term begins and is invoiced. The notice date is the last day on which the organisation can cancel or, under most contracts, reduce what it renews. A contract with automatic renewal that is not changed by the notice date continues as it is.

What can you ask a SaaS vendor for at renewal?

A seat count that matches what is needed, a move of some seats to a lower tier, the published list price where the organisation pays more, any offer the vendor publishes for which the organisation meets the conditions, and better terms such as a cap on price increases or a shorter notice period. Every request should rest on a figure from the organisation's own data.

What if the notice date has already passed?

The contract normally renews as it is. Ask the vendor anyway, since some agree to a change in return for a longer term or a different plan, and unassign the unused seats so they can be reused for joiners instead of buying more. Then put the next notice date in the calendar with enough lead time.

Does a multi-year contract or annual prepayment save money?

Only what the vendor quotes in writing. Such offers exchange a lower price for a commitment, and a commitment to more seats than are needed costs more than it saves. Fix the seat count first, then ask for the offer, and compare the quoted total over the whole term with the current terms.