How to prove procurement savings
A procurement saving is proven when it shows on what is billed, which means a lower unit price on later invoices, fewer seats on the renewal invoice or a credit note. Before that it is either in question, meaning computed from data and confirmed by nobody, or agreed, meaning someone has committed to it. Report the three stages separately, keep amounts recovered once apart from savings that recur every year, fix the price before at the moment of the agreement, and measure with the quantity billed times the difference between the price before and the price billed.
A saving is proven when it shows on what is billed: a lower unit price on later invoices, fewer seats on the next renewal invoice, a credit note for a duplicate. Everything before that is a figure on its way to becoming a saving. The method is to name the stage each figure has reached, and to measure on invoices.
Three stages of a saving
| Stage | What it means | Evidence | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| In question | Computed from data. Nobody has confirmed it | The calculation and its inputs | 6 seats without activity for 90 days, times the price per seat |
| Agreed | Someone has committed to it | The holder's release, the supplier's confirmed offer and the award, the vendor's written confirmation | A supplier offers 4.60 instead of 5.00 and receives the award |
| Realised | It shows on what is billed | An invoice or a credit note | The month's invoices bill 4.60 |
A report that adds the three stages into one figure is wrong in a predictable direction, because the amounts in question are always the largest. Each stage gets its own column, and a figure moves to the next one only when the evidence exists.
One-off and yearly
An amount recovered once and a saving that recurs are different things. The refund of a duplicate invoice, a corrected arithmetic error and an amount billed above the agreed price come back once. A lower unit price, a removed seat and a cheaper plan take effect every year for as long as they hold.
The two kinds are summed apart. A one-off amount also stays settled once it is done: the same duplicate is not found and counted again next quarter. A report that shows "savings of 50,000.00" without saying which part comes back every year tells finance nothing it can plan with.
The baseline is what was paid before
Every saving is a difference, and the argument is usually about the number it is subtracted from. The baseline that holds up is the last price actually paid, taken from invoices. Fix it at the moment the new price is agreed and store it with the agreement, so that nobody can choose a more flattering one later.
Two quantities are needed, and they must not be mixed. The yearly quantity from twelve months of invoices is what offers are priced for when you compare supplier offers. The realised saving uses the quantity that is actually billed afterwards.
Measuring on invoices
For every later invoice line bought under the agreement:
saving = quantity billed × (price before − price billed)
A worked example with invented figures. The price before was 5.00, the agreed price is 4.60, and the month brings three invoice lines.
| Invoice line | Quantity | Price billed | Calculation | Saving |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 1,200 | 4.60 | 1,200 × (5.00 − 4.60) | 480.00 |
| B | 800 | 4.60 | 800 × (5.00 − 4.60) | 320.00 |
| C | 500 | 5.20 | 500 × (5.00 − 5.20) | −100.00 |
The month's realised saving is 700.00. Line C was billed above the old price and counts negative. Because it is also above the agreed price, it is an invoice finding as well: 500 × (5.20 − 4.60) = 300.00 to claim back, once. Checking later invoices against agreements is covered in price agreements on invoices.
For licences the logic is the same with different evidence. The seats in question come from the comparison of seat list and activity, as in finding unused software licences. The saving is realised when the seats are gone from the subscription, and it is counted month by month over the following year, not as one sum on the day of the decision.
What does not count
- A benchmark. What other organisations are said to save is no figure of yours.
- The supplier's first offer as baseline. Negotiating from 5.40 down to 4.90 is no saving when you paid 4.80 before.
- A list price nobody paid.
- A forecast quantity. If less is bought than planned, less is saved.
- An unverified price. A figure that rests on a researched price is shown with that label and kept out of the total.
- An offer nobody confirmed. Prices that a model read from a supplier's mail are a draft until a person has confirmed them.
What a savings report shows per line
- What it is about: the finding, the agreement, the item or the application.
- The stage: in question, agreed or realised.
- The kind: once or yearly.
- The calculation with its inputs.
- The source of each input: which invoice, which seat list, which offer.
- Who confirmed it and when.
A line that cannot fill the fourth and fifth point belongs in a list of ideas. A report built this way survives the question finance always asks, which is where the saving shows in the accounts.
How Cureman does it
Cureman computes every saving by deterministic code and shows the calculation, as explained in why AI must not invent figures. No benchmark is used: a saving nobody has quoted or billed is not counted, and a request for quotation shows no figure until an offer has arrived. Each module meters what can be shown. Licence optimisation counts the annual saving of findings that were marked done, spread over the twelve months after completion. Invoice audit counts the amounts recovered through findings marked done in the month, and shows them as recovered once, apart from yearly savings. Sourcing stores the price before with every price agreement and measures on the month's invoices: quantity times the difference between the price before and the price billed, with a line billed above the old price counting negative. The AI gateway counts the price difference between the requested and the served model on routed requests, minus what the classification cost. Figures that rest on something unverified are shown and not added up, and every decision carries a note saying whose figure its worth is. Where a module is charged as a share of savings, the share is taken from these metered figures; see pricing. The rules are on the page about principles, and how it works describes the daily work from a finding to a decision.
Questions and answers
When does a procurement saving count as realised?
- When it can be seen on what is billed or paid. For an agreed price that is every later invoice line billed below the price before. For licences it is the renewal or monthly invoice with fewer seats or a cheaper plan, and for an invoice error it is the credit note or the refund.
What is the difference between a one-off and a yearly saving?
- A one-off amount is recovered once, for example the refund of a duplicate invoice. A yearly saving recurs for as long as the lower price or the smaller seat count holds. The two are reported in separate columns and never added into one figure.
Which baseline should a saving be measured against?
- Against what was actually paid before, which is the last price paid for the item, taken from invoices and fixed at the moment the new price is agreed. A supplier's first offer, a list price nobody paid and a budget figure are not baselines, because no money was spent at those prices.
Is cost avoidance a saving?
- Cost avoidance, such as a price increase that was negotiated away, is a result worth reporting, but it does not reduce what is paid compared with before. Report it on a line of its own with its own calculation and keep it out of the savings total.
How does Cureman measure savings?
- Each module of Cureman meters what can be shown. For licences that is the annual saving of findings marked done, spread over the twelve months after completion. For invoices it is the amounts recorded as recovered, and for sourcing it is measured on later invoices as quantity times the difference between the price before and the price billed. Unverified figures are shown and not added up.