Negotiation rounds with suppliers: targets and wording
A negotiation round is one written counter-offer per supplier after the offers have been compared. It names the items on which you are still apart, the supplier's price and your target for each, and a date for a revised offer. A target price needs a source: the lowest price another supplier offered for that item, or today's price less a reduction you set before asking. What you say about competing offers must be true and comes from the comparison. Stop when nothing is left to ask, when a supplier says the price is final, or when the remaining gap is smaller than the cost of another round.
A negotiation round is a written counter-offer to each supplier that is still in the running: these are the items on which we are apart, this is your price, this is our target, please send a revised offer by this date. It comes after the offers have been put on the same basis, as described in comparing supplier offers, because the comparison is where every target and every statement in the round comes from.
Where a target price comes from
There are two honest sources for a target, and both are figures you already have.
- The best price another supplier offered for the same item. It exists, it is in your comparison table, and you can say so.
- Today's price less the reduction you set. Decide before the request goes out what you want to reach against what you pay today. That goal is yours and stays internal; what the supplier sees is the resulting price per item.
Take the lower of the two. It becomes an ask only when it lies below what this supplier has already offered. If the supplier is already at or below both, there is nothing to ask for on that item, and asking anyway teaches the supplier that your targets are arbitrary.
There is no third source. A price that nobody offered and no target of yours justifies is an invention.
A worked example
The figures are invented. Two suppliers quoted three items; supplier A delivers today. The buyer's own target against today's prices of 6.00, 15.00 and 8.00 works out at 5.70, 14.25 and 7.60.
The position for supplier A:
| Item | Quantity per year | A offered | Best other offer | Own target | Ask | Gap per year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gloves, box | 1,200 | 5.80 | 5.50 | 5.70 | 5.50 | 360.00 |
| Paper towels, pack | 400 | 14.50 | 15.00 | 14.25 | 14.25 | 100.00 |
| Disinfectant, bottle | 300 | 8.00 | 7.50 | 7.60 | 7.50 | 150.00 |
The gap per year is (offered − ask) × quantity, and adds up to 610.00. If A met every ask, its total of 15,160.00 would fall to 14,550.00.
Supplier B offered 5.50, 15.00 and 7.50. It is already the lowest on gloves and disinfectant and below the buyer's own target on both, so the only ask to B is the paper towels at 14.25: a gap of 0.75 × 400 = 300.00.
What may be said about other offers
| Statement | When it may be made |
|---|---|
| "Your offer is currently the lowest overall." | It has the lowest total among the complete offers |
| "Your offer is currently not the lowest overall." | Another complete offer has a lower total |
| "Another supplier has offered this price." | True for that item, and you have decided to disclose it |
| Nothing about other offers | There is only one offer, or this offer covers only some of the delivery sites and cannot be ranked against offers for all of them |
What may never be said: an offer that does not exist, a deadline you made up, a volume you do not intend to buy, the name of the competing supplier, or the content of its quotation. Apart from being untrue, a bluff is expensive. Suppliers in one market talk to each other, and the first target that turns out to be invented devalues every later one.
Telling a supplier that it is currently the lowest can feel like giving away leverage. It is still better than silence followed by an ask that the supplier cannot place, and it does not stop you from asking for the items where another supplier is cheaper.
Wording a counter-offer
Keep it short, per item, and without adjectives. An example with invented figures:
Thank you for your quotation. Overall it is currently not the lowest we have received. On the following items we are still apart: gloves, your offer 5.80, our target 5.50, a price another supplier has offered; paper towels, your offer 14.50, our target 14.25. Can you move towards us on these? Please send a revised quotation by 12 December.
- Ask per item, not for a reduction on everything. A supplier can check an item price against its own costs; it cannot do anything with a general appeal.
- Offer what costs you little. A longer term, fewer and larger deliveries, a shorter payment period or bundled sites can be worth more to the supplier than to you. Offer only what you can actually deliver.
- Do not promise the award. "If you meet these prices you will get the order" is a commitment. Say that you will decide once the revised offers are in.
- Do not threaten. A date and a list of items are enough.
How many rounds, and when to stop
Decide before the first round how many there will be, and tell suppliers when a round is the last. A supplier who expects a further round holds something back, and one who was told "last round" twice will hold back next time as well.
Stop when one of these is true:
- Nothing is left to ask: the best offer is the lowest on every item and meets your own target.
- The supplier has said that its price is final.
- The remaining gap per year is smaller than what another round or a change of supplier would cost you in work.
- The date by which you need the goods leaves no room.
Then award, confirm the prices in writing, and send the other suppliers a short, polite note. From then on the agreed prices have to show up on invoices: see checking invoices against agreed prices.
What goes wrong
- Bluffing. One invented offer is enough to make every true statement doubtful.
- Negotiating the total only. "Can you do better overall?" gets a small gesture. Item prices with a source get an answer.
- Treating an incomplete offer as the cheapest. It has no rank until it quotes everything.
- Leaving the current supplier out. It knows the business best and often has the most room to move once it sees that the terms are under review.
How Cureman does it
Cureman computes the position for each supplier from the offers on the table. For every item the target is the lower of the best price another supplier offered and today's price reduced by the target the buyer set on the event, and it is an ask only when it lies below the supplier's own offer. The target reduction itself is never sent. One counter-offer per supplier is drafted from that position. The list of items with the supplier's price and the target is filled in from the event, and what the message says about the competition is derived from the comparison: lowest overall, not the lowest, or nothing. If the event allows it, the message says that a target is a price another supplier offered, never whose. A model draft that adds a figure, a link or a claim of its own is replaced by the template, so no message claims an offer that does not exist. A person approves and sends each counter-offer, as argued in human approval for AI agents, and suppliers revise through the same quote link. On award the offered prices become price agreements. The module is described under sourcing and negotiation.
Questions and answers
How do you set a target price for a negotiation?
- Per item, from two sources. One is the lowest price another supplier has offered for the same item. The other is today's price less the reduction you set for yourself before asking. Take the lower of the two, and ask for it only if it lies below what this supplier has offered. A price with neither source behind it is a wish, and a supplier will treat it as one.
May a buyer tell a supplier what other suppliers offered?
- You may say what is true and what you decided to disclose, for example that the offer is currently not the lowest overall, or that a target price is one another supplier has offered. Do not name the other supplier and do not forward its quotation. Never state an offer that does not exist.
How many negotiation rounds are sensible?
- As few as it takes. One round after the first offers is often enough for standard purchases, and a second is justified when the first moved prices and a gap remains. Decide the number before you start and announce a round as the last one only if it is.
When should a negotiation stop?
- When the best offer is already the lowest on every item and meets your own target, when a supplier has said its price is final, when the remaining gap per year is smaller than the effort of another round or of changing supplier, or when the date by which you need the goods leaves no time. Then award and tell the others.
Does Cureman negotiate with suppliers by itself?
- No. Cureman computes for every supplier and item what to ask for and drafts one counter-offer per supplier. A person approves and sends each message, and every further round is prepared in the same way and released by a person. It does not accept an offer and it does not negotiate in a loop.