Invoices and spend

Invoice audit checklist: what to check on every invoice

Updated 6 min readMarkdown
In short

A supplier invoice is ready to pay when six questions are answered. Is it a complete invoice addressed to you? Do its own figures add up? Do quantity and price match what was ordered, delivered and agreed? Has it been billed before? Does its period overlap one already billed? Is the bank account the one on record? The first two checks need only the document, the other four need your records, and all of them are comparisons that can be written down as rules.

An invoice audit answers one question before money leaves: is this amount owed, to this supplier, into this account? The answer comes from six checks. Two compare the invoice with itself. Four compare it with what you already know: orders, deliveries, agreed prices, earlier invoices and the supplier's record.

The six checks at a glance

CheckQuestionCompared with
FormalIs this a complete invoice, addressed to us?The document itself
ArithmeticDo its figures agree with each other?The document itself
FactualWas this ordered, received and priced as agreed?Order, delivery note, price agreement
DuplicateHas this been billed before?Earlier invoices of the same supplier
PeriodDoes the billed period overlap one already billed?Earlier invoices for the same item
Bank detailsIs this the account we know?The supplier's record and earlier invoices

Do them in this order. A document that fails the formal check is sent back before anyone spends time on its prices.

1. Formal check: a complete invoice, addressed to you

Check that the document is an invoice and not a reminder, an order confirmation or a delivery note, and that it names your legal entity. Then check the details an invoice has to carry: the supplier's name and address, its tax number or VAT identification number, the invoice date, a unique invoice number, what was supplied and how much of it, when it was supplied, the net amount by tax rate, the tax rate and the tax amount.

In Germany these mandatory details are listed in § 14 (4) of the VAT Act (UStG); an invoice that lacks them puts the input tax deduction at risk. Other countries have their own lists. This is a description of the rule, not legal or tax advice.

2. Arithmetic check: the invoice agrees with itself

Four sums, each with a tolerance for rounding:

  1. Quantity × unit price gives each line amount.
  2. The line amounts add up to the net total.
  3. The line amounts at their tax rates give the tax amount.
  4. Net plus tax gives the gross total.

A worked example with invented figures. An invoice has three lines: 10 × 12.00 = 120.00, 4 × 50.00 = 200.00 and 1 × 80.00 = 80.00. The lines add up to 400.00. At 19 % VAT the tax is 76.00 and the gross total 476.00. The document states a net total of 410.00, tax of 77.90 and a gross total of 487.90. Sums 3 and 4 pass, because the tax and the gross follow from the stated net. Sum 2 fails: the net total is 10.00 above the lines, which makes 11.90 gross that no line explains.

Also check that the due date is not before the invoice date. It sounds trivial and catches documents with a mistyped year.

3. Factual check: ordered, received, priced as agreed

This is the three-way match: invoice against order against goods receipt or service confirmation.

  • Quantity. The billed quantity is not above the quantity received. Partial deliveries are billed in parts.
  • Price. The unit price is the price of the order or of the price agreement valid on the invoice date, in the same unit. A price per box cannot be compared with a price per piece.
  • Extras. Freight, minimum-quantity surcharges and packaging are billed only where the order or the contract allows them.

Where no order exists, the comparison is with the last price paid for the same item. A unit price that has risen since the last invoice is not an error, but somebody should have agreed to it. How to find such changes line by line is described in finding price increases on invoices.

4. Duplicate check: billed before

The same invoice arrives twice more often than one expects: once by post and once by email, once as the original and once attached to a reminder. Compare supplier, invoice number and gross amount with everything already on record, and write the number in a normalised form first, so that RE-2026/0042 and RE 2026 42 are recognised as one. Then look for the harder case: the same supplier, amount and date under a different number. The matching rules are in detecting duplicate invoices.

5. Period check: the same service billed twice

Subscriptions, maintenance, rent and leases are billed for periods. Two invoices from one supplier for the same item and the same quantity whose periods overlap deserve a look, even when their numbers and amounts differ. Typical causes are a change of plan in the middle of a term, a renewal invoice sent before the old term ended, and a move from monthly to yearly billing. A second charge for the same period can be legitimate, for example for a second site, so this check ends with a question to the supplier and not with a deduction.

6. Bank details: the account on record

Compare the IBAN on the invoice with the one on the supplier's record and on its earlier invoices. A new account on an invoice from a known supplier is the pattern of payment diversion fraud. Do not update the record from the invoice and do not ask by replying to it. Call a contact you already have. The procedure is in changed bank details on invoices.

What goes wrong

  • Checking only the total. A wrong line and a correct total can sit on the same document; overcharges live in the lines.
  • Trusting what was read. Figures typed from a PDF or read by software can be misread. The arithmetic check catches most of this, which is one reason to run it first. Structured e-invoices do not have the problem.
  • Tolerances without a rule. "Small differences are waved through" turns into a habit suppliers can learn. Write the tolerance down.
  • Finding and not following up. A duplicate that was paid is money to recover once. Note who asked for the credit note and when it arrived.

How Cureman does it

Cureman takes invoices as uploads, structured e-invoices, CSV exports or through an ingest endpoint. XRechnung, Peppol, ZUGFeRD and Factur-X are parsed without a model. A PDF or a photo is read by a model and stays labelled "read by model" until a person has reviewed it. Whoever read the document, the same arithmetic runs on it: required details, lines against the net total, quantity times unit price, net plus tax, tax against the line rates, and the dates, with a tolerance of one cent per line added up. An invoice that fails a check waits for review with the failing check named.

Across invoices of the last twelve months, the audit looks for duplicates, differences in the supplier's favour, unit prices above an agreed price, periods billed twice and changed bank accounts. Each finding shows what was compared and the calculation. Amounts found this way are shown as recoverable once and are never added to yearly savings; payments are not known to the system, so a person decides what to claim. The module is described on the page about invoice audit and spend analysis.

Questions and answers

What should be checked on a supplier invoice before paying?

Six things. The formal details are complete, the figures on the document add up, quantity and price match the order, the delivery and any agreed price, the invoice has not been billed before, its billing period does not overlap an earlier invoice, and the bank account is the one on record for the supplier. The first two need only the document, the rest need your own records.

What is the difference between the arithmetic check and the factual check?

The arithmetic check asks whether the invoice agrees with itself, so lines add up to the net total and net plus tax gives the gross. The factual check asks whether the invoice agrees with reality, so the goods or services were ordered and received and the price is the one agreed. An invoice can pass the first and fail the second.

How much rounding difference is acceptable on an invoice?

Rounding arises once per line, because each line amount is rounded to a cent before it is added up. A workable rule is one cent per line that is added, with a small minimum for short invoices. Anything above that is a difference to explain, not rounding.

Does a structured e-invoice still need to be checked?

Yes. An e-invoice removes reading errors, because the supplier's system wrote the figures as data. It does not tell you whether the price is the agreed one, whether the same delivery was billed twice or whether the bank account has changed. Those checks compare the invoice with your records and stay the same.