Sourcing

How to follow up with suppliers who do not answer

Updated 6 min readMarkdown
In short

Follow up once in writing, in the same thread, and make it easy to answer, including with a no. For a request for quotation, send one reminder a few days before the deadline to the suppliers that have not answered. For a question without a deadline, follow up after a fixed number of working days, at most twice. After that the matter goes back to a person, who calls, tries another contact or closes it. A follow-up repeats what was asked and adds no new figures. An out-of-office note is not an answer, and a bounce means the address is wrong.

Silence from a supplier is not a refusal. The request went to a general inbox, the contact is away, the question was unclear, or the supplier does not want to quote and finds it easier not to say so. A good follow-up helps in each of these cases: it arrives at the right moment, it repeats the question, and it offers an easy way out. It is sent once or twice, not six times.

Why suppliers do not answer

ReasonHow you noticeWhat helps
Wrong contactGeneral address, no name, no reaction at allAsk who handles quotations, or call the switchboard
Request unclear or too much workQuestions back, or silence from several suppliers at onceFix the request for everyone, not only for the one who asked
Does not want to quoteSilence up to the deadlineSay in the request that a short refusal is welcome
Contact is awayOut-of-office noteWrite to the stand-in and note the return date
Message did not arriveDelivery failure, or nothingAnother address, or the contact form on the supplier's website

The second line deserves attention. If three of five suppliers stay silent, the problem is probably the request. What a request needs so that a supplier can answer it without calling is in writing a request for quotation.

A timetable

WhenWhat happens
With the requestState the deadline as a date. Say that a short note declining to quote is welcome
Three days before the deadlineOne reminder to those that have neither quoted nor declined
On the deadlineCompare what has arrived. If you extend, extend for everyone and say so
A question without a deadline, such as a credit note or a price confirmationFirst follow-up after four working days, a second one four working days later
After the last follow-upA person decides: call, try another contact, or close the matter

Count working days, not calendar days. A follow-up on Monday morning to a message sent on Friday afternoon reads as impatience.

Wording

A reminder for a request for quotation:

We asked you for a quotation for cleaning supplies and have not received one yet. The deadline is 30 November. If you prefer not to quote, a short note is enough.

A follow-up on another matter:

I am following up on my message of 3 November. Could you let me know when I can expect a reply, or who else I should write to?

What both have in common:

  • They are replies in the same thread. The supplier sees the original below and does not have to search.
  • They add no figures. A follow-up with a new quantity or price is a new request and has to be read and approved as one.
  • They offer a way out. "A short note is enough" and "who else should I write to" produce answers where "we urgently await your reply" produces nothing.
  • They invent no urgency. No "last chance", no deadline that does not exist, no hint at consequences you will not draw.

What counts as an answer

  • An offer or a refusal is an answer. Record the refusal, so that this supplier gets no reminder.
  • "We will get back to you by Friday" is an answer that starts a new wait until Friday.
  • An out-of-office note is not an answer. The wait goes on.
  • A delivery failure is not an answer and not silence either. The message did not arrive; someone has to find another address.
  • An answer by another route, such as a phone call or an email to a colleague, is an answer. Note it in the thread, or the supplier gets a reminder for something it has dealt with.

Keep the thread

A conversation with a supplier about one matter belongs in one place: the request, the reminder, the reply and the offer, in order. Then a colleague can take over during a holiday, nobody asks the same question twice, and an offer that arrives by email can be traced to the request it answers.

Two habits make that possible. Write from a mailbox whose replies the team can see, not from a personal inbox. And reply within the existing thread instead of starting a new email with a new subject, because mail programs and suppliers both sort by subject.

When to stop, and who takes over

A written follow-up that is repeated without limit trains the supplier to ignore you. Set the number in advance, usually two, and decide what happens next.

In a request for quotation the answer is simple: the comparison is made with the offers that arrived, as described in comparing supplier offers, and the silent supplier is out for this round. The exception is the supplier that delivers today. If it does not answer, call, because its silence has consequences for both sides.

In other matters, such as a credit note that is owed, the unanswered conversation goes back to a named person with three options: call, write to someone else at the supplier, or close it with a note. It should appear on that person's list of things to decide, next to everything else that waits for them; see the decision list in procurement.

What goes wrong

  • Reminding a supplier that has answered. The reply went to another inbox and nobody noted it.
  • A reminder with changed figures. Nobody approved those figures.
  • Extending the deadline for one supplier. The others quoted under more pressure and will remember.
  • Automatic chains. A fourth and fifth automatic email is no longer a follow-up but a nuisance.
  • A new thread for every message. The history is then spread over five subjects.

How Cureman does it

In Cureman every message to a supplier belongs to a conversation. It goes out from the organisation's connected mailbox where there is one, and the reply is filed with the sourcing event by itself. From a connected mailbox only replies to conversations started in Cureman are stored; of other mail only the sender is looked at. A request for quotation follows the deadline of its event: one reminder in fixed words goes out three days before the deadline to suppliers that were asked and have not answered. It repeats a request a person approved, and nothing else of an event is sent without a person. Other conversations with suppliers and vendors run on a follow-up clock: after a set number of working days without a reply, four by default, a follow-up is drafted from fixed wording without figures and waits for approval. Only the first one may go out by itself, and only where the organisation switched that on. After the last one, two by default, the conversation comes back to a person as unanswered. A reply stops the clock and discards a waiting draft, an out-of-office note does not count as an answer, and a bounce becomes a decision for a person. Why the line is drawn there is the subject of human approval for AI agents. The module is described under sourcing and negotiation.

Questions and answers

When should a supplier be reminded of a request for quotation?

Once, a few days before the deadline, and only if the supplier has neither quoted nor declined. Three days before the deadline leaves enough time to answer and is late enough that most suppliers who meant to quote have done so. Do not send it the day after the request.

How many follow-ups are appropriate?

Two written follow-ups are enough for most matters. If the first and the second get no reply, a third email will not either. At that point someone should pick up the phone, find another contact at the supplier, or close the matter and note why.

Is an out-of-office reply an answer?

No. It tells you when the person is back and sometimes who stands in. Note the date, write to the stand-in if one is named, and let the waiting period run on. A delivery failure is different, because it means the message never arrived and you need another address.

Should a follow-up contain new terms or a new deadline?

No. A follow-up repeats what was asked and points to the original message. New quantities, prices or dates belong in a new message that someone has read and approved, and a deadline that is extended for one supplier has to be extended for all of them.

Does Cureman send reminders to suppliers automatically?

One, in fixed words, and it repeats a request a person approved. For a request for quotation it goes out three days before the deadline to suppliers that were asked and have not answered. In other conversations with suppliers and vendors the first follow-up goes out by itself only where the organisation switched that on. Every further follow-up is a draft that a person releases.